Review of Lucio Silla at Opera Atelier Toronto

On Sunday afternoon, April 10, 2016, Opera Atelier of Toronto presented “Lucio Silla” in two acts by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. The steel grey Ontario sky and frosty winds melted away inside the Hallsumptuous Elgin Theater on Yonge Street. Ticketholders were welcomed with tall, gilded mirrors and plush garnet carpeting. It is an entry designed for well-dressed people in evening gowns and pearls. The atmosphere is sophisticated. How funny than to see the concession stand selling M&M candies. At the opera? Sure! It is after all Mozart, I think he would have snuck a bag into the theater to enjoy with the show. The premier was in Milan Italy December 1772. Two hundred and forty-four years later, it was my turn to be present when the curtain rose.

Of all Mozart’s compositions, this one holds special meaning, I fell in love with this story the first time I heard, Giunia and Cecilio’s duetto: d’elisio in sen m’ attendi.

Giunia sings out at the sight of Cecilio “In Elysium await me, shade of all I own most dear, so that heaven soon, o God, soon may unite me to thee.”

Cecilio’s reply, “Adored, dear wife, in thy sweet countenance alone my faithful soul finds Sweet Elysium again.”

The libretto by Giovanni de Gamerra reads like baroque poetry. The lovers meet at the grave of Giunia’s recently deceased father Senator Marius. She thought Cecilio died too at the hands of Silla and was looking at his ghost. She came to find her way in the wake of Silla’s victorious ascension as Emperor of Rome. The moment these two lovers reunite is out of this world. The joy escalates through the rise of a trembling soprano as the musical notes leap with her heart. Her soul comes out of the morass to shake the heavens with its passion at the sight of him. Mozart composed love as music. The tone, texture, and resonance is so powerful it balances the heart chakra. These two are soulmates. Their hearts only beat for each other.

This opera is the one that opened me to the beauty of this theatrical art. Several years ago, I took courses in music appreciation of classical music and opera. I chose famed mezzo-soprano Ceclia Bartoli as the artist to study. By chance, I bought her CD titled Mozart Arias. Three arias and the duet from Lucio Silla are on the disc. Eventually, I acquired the CD of this opera with maestro Wien Nikolaus Harnoncourt. There was no DVD for rent or purchase. When a web search for the opera season turned up this production, I could not resist the chance to see it.

The 1,500-seat theater includes a balcony and traditional orchestra pit. The harpsichord player sits to the right side of the stage above the pit. This is where Mozart would have been at the premier. This instrument moves the story along during recitative or spoken/sung dialog telling the story. Conductor David Fallis led the Tafelmusik Baroque 30 piece orchestra of Ontario. There are so many moments during the opera when the players were not singing but Mozart continued moving the story and setting the tone with the notes. Up from the pit floated one graceful enchanting note after another. There is no separation between the power of voice and instruments. Each is as exquisite as the other is. Mozart moves us emotionally and invites us to understand the players most intimately by the language of his music. At sixteen years old, he showed incredible skill in this his eighth operatic composition.

HarpsichordTafelmusik Baroque string section truly sounded lighter in the strings. I wondered if the instruments were indeed from the baroque era, Marketing Manager Tim Crouch said, “In this case, the orchestra is using classical instruments, a time-period which happened a little later than baroque (though the same is true of our baroque instruments), and they’re a combination of original instruments and reproductions. Most of the string instruments date from the 18th century – restored to their original condition. Most if not all the bows are new, as are all the winds, brass, percussion, and keyboard. All new instruments are “copies” constructed according to 18th-century models and techniques. String instruments get better over time, while the others tend to deteriorate, hence the reproductions.” Everything and everyone gave a grand performance. An opera in a movie theater or on DVD is an option for viewing, but nothing compares when art is crafted live before the eyes.

Highlights from the opera seria are the carefully choreographed duel with rapiers between Cecilio and Silla’s guards. There was a startling time shift as the actors slowed the duel to a quarter normal speed. Cecilio is outraged as Silla attempts to take Giunia as his “prize” bride. The blades moved to the vocal and musical notes. Wow! Kudos to Jennifer Parr and Jack Rennie for fight choreography. The original opera included ballet dancers. In fact, Mozart wrote into the sheet music where the dancers are to come in.  This explained long periods of music on the CD. Finally, I understood as the artists of the Atelier Ballet graced the stage.

This opera is normally in three acts. A few arias were not performed. Apparently, this happens depending on the size of the stage and circumstances. As I learned this opera by ear, I knew a gap in my auditory memory. The missing parts helped the audience understand how vicious a man Silla was, and how ardently the couple are bonded. Their steadfast love beyond the corporeal becomes evident even to Silla and he has a moment of doubt as to what to do. He wants Giunia out of lust. He despises her rejection. He struggles even to understand how she could behave with such scorn. The missing recitative and arias helped inform the audience of just how despicable a character he was. The opera was fine, just some of the emotional strength was lost with the trimming.

In the end, Silla performed by Kresimir Spicer made a remarkable move by leaving the stage and coming right out in front of the orchestra pit. He pours out his confusion over what to do. He feels his conscience perhaps for the first time ever. He actually listens to the inner voice. He is a murderer. Yet, confronted by the strength of love, he hesitates. It was fabulous to sit there and witness this soliloquy. Mozart’s gift is the ability to draw out the part of their character the audience can identify with. Somewhere in the notes and words, the sway, tone and pacing, we sense the person there. We can feel their humanity whatever the character.

mozartThe performance was satisfying in every way. Artistic directors Marshall Pynkoski and Jeannette Lajeunesse Zingg brought the magic of this opera to the stage once again. I travelled many miles to see this. The only thing missing was Mozart himself. I kept looking at the harpsichord player and imagining what it could have been like, this small kid up there conducting the singers and musicians. He is one of the immortals. His body gave up but every opera season since his death, one of his operas is performed somewhere. What a remarkable achievement! Bravi a tutti!

Copyright 2016 by Frances Ann Wychorski



Opera! Here We Go! How to Appreciate and Listen to Opera ~ Part II

The Aria Continued

This is the second of a series of articles about how to listen to and appreciate opera. For whatever reason, the interest to appreciate opera comes and so what to do? How can the average person gain entry into this fine art. I have been a casual listener of classical and operatic music for some time. Only in the last year have I taken a light interest into a fun and exciting hobby. I have used the available resources to find a way into this grand theater and hope to take a few readers along with me. This article will describe an aria in finer detail and provide a few samples for the reader to listen to. Hopefully, the beauty and delight I have found will encourage the curious beginner to explore. Opera at its core is story telling expressed through the fine arts of music and vocal artistry. Opera is the human experience of emotions, desires and dreams.

The reader can set aside the notion of needing to understand the language in which the opera is sung. The idea is to appreciate beautiful music, staging, costumes, vocal artistry and good acting. Opera is a fine art. Opera tells a complex story. The stories can be melodramas, light comedies or mythological tales. The stories reflect the complexity of a situation in life. The characters are being challenged in some way in the course of their lives. We are watching them work out the challenge. An opera is so written as to be a work of art and transport the viewer out of the ordinary and into a living artistic experience. There are plenty of fans who understand the basic story and appreciate the subtitles provided at the theater or on the DVD. But, many simply want to be swept into the sensory experience of opera.

The first article introduced and explained some opera lingo including an aria, a dramatic tenor and an operatic style called: zarzuela. Several means by which to view opera where included such as rental of DVD’s from the public library, attending a simulcast of a Metropolitan Opera broadcast at a local theater or watching Great Performances on PBS Television. I enjoy listening to CD’s of a complete opera during my commute time. The stereo system in my car is quite good and, I have a period ranging from 15 to 60 minutes of listening time. I also have several CD’s of opera arias by my favorite artist to enjoy. Many CD’s can be acquired through a wide variety of resources such as Amazon, Sales at Public Libraries or local Used CD retailers. A tip on buying CD’s, always look for the boxed set to ensure you get the full opera with libretto. The reading material is quite instructive and entertaining.

Aria ~ Air

An aria is a solo number within an opera performed by the vocal artist. An aria is created to showcase the vocal range and beauty of the voice. An aria can be a soliloquy. And, sometimes be a showstopper; a moment of great wonder to see and hear. An aria is center stage for the solo vocal artist and her/his moment to tell their story. There will be several arias throughout an opera and the principal characters in the story will have several opportunities to perform.

An aria can also be thought of as the solo portion in a concerto. A concerto is a musical composition for a single instrument such as piano, violin or cello and accompanied by an orchestra. A concerto is a dance between the orchestra and the solo instrument. The overall goal of an instrument aria is to celebrate the star of the show. The star being the piano, violin, cello, etc… Depending on the composition, the orchestra can at times appear to be competing with the soloist. That is up to the discretion of the composer and like anything of beauty, in the eye of the beholder.

Like all art, it is subject to personal preference. Opera singers have a variety of different vocal styles and ranges. By listening to a wide variety of opera arias by different singers, one day the listener will discover their favorite or favorites. Once the preferred voice is heard, it makes it much more fun to listen to different operas and start to appreciate this art. The listener will know when they hear what delights their ears.

An aria is as good as the musical composition, libretto and performance. Depending on the skill of the composer, the music that is heard before, during and after the artists performance of the aria can enhance or restrict an otherwise beautiful moment. The singer has the task of conveying the emotional characteristics of the libretto and the character they are portraying. The best opera singers are also good actors. The musical instruments should not compete with the singer as in a concerto, they support the performance and move the story forward. All eyes and ears are on the singer.

One important note for the newbie; the opera stage does not have a microphone. The audience is relying on the ability of the theater and artists to project the sounds of their instruments and voices out. Opera singers must be able to sing with clarity and power. The orchestra and vocal artists must work together to not overwhelm one or the other. The conductor’s job is to steer everybody into a perfect combination of the two.

Libretto ~ Little Book

Libretto in Italian literally means little book. It is the dry text of the story around which the opera is Lucio_Silla_-_libretocomposed. The libretto is written more often than not by a separate person but can be in collaboration with the musical composer. It can be that a libretto was written well before the composer was born and is the basic source material for the opera. The composer’s task is to take the libretto and set the whole story to music. The composer creates the arias and tells the vocal artist where and how to sing the words. Some librettos are bits of poetry and help the story be a more enjoyable experience. It’s quite remarkable how a composer can take a relatively short piece at times and create a work of art.

Aria ~ “Il tenero momento”

Here is an example of a short libretto, but in the right hands, what it can become.

No. 2 Aria – Cecilio “Il tenero momento” 8:06 minutes
The tender moment,
Reward of love so great,
Already fills my heart
With sweet thoughts.
And how shall that joy be,
Which awaits me at her side,
When the very thought alone
So entices my rapture?
LUCIO SILLA: Opera seria in three acts
Music by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Libretto by Giovanni de Gamerra
Premiere Performance 26 December 1772, Milan (Teatro Regio Ducal)

LUCIO SILLA, dictator (Tenor)
GIUNIA, daughter of Gaius Marius and betrothed to Cecilio (Soprano)
CECILIO, banished senator (Soprano)
LUCIO CINNA, Roman patrician, friend of Cecilio and secret opponent of Lucio Silla (Soprano)
CELIA, sister to Silla (Soprano)
AUFIDIO, tribune and friend of Silla (Tenor)
Time: During the dictatorship of Lucius Cornelius Sulla (138-78 BC) Rome

FYI – The role of Cecilio is played by a woman. In the time it was staged, Cecilio would have been sung by a Castrato. In modern times, the role often goes to a mezzosoprano or contralto (vocal style).

This is a young Mozart at his finest. The music is as important an element to this aria as the voice. The music sets the melody, energy and emotion of this aria. This is beautifully composed and sung. Mozart has a signature style of presenting emotions and situations in a subtle but expressive manner. When in high, loving spirits, Mozart arias are like listening to champagne. The sense of feeling the emotion can be felt in the body and heart. This aria is an expression of great love and commitment between two soulmates. Cecilio and Giunia are betrothed and devoted to one another in this and the next life.

Mozart is often considered to be one of the finest, if not the finest composer of classical music and operas. In this aria, I often think that the music could stand alone and be enjoyed without the vocal. However, the combination is what defines Mozart and his greatness. He skillfully “frames” the voice with the music and creates a buoyant, full bodied aria.

The singer is Cecilia Bartoli, a mezzosoprano noted for her fine pitch. Ms. Bartoli is adept at matching her vocals to that of the instruments played. Both support and enhance the other. In my limited and humble opinion, this is fine art. This is the moment I fell in love with opera. This opera turned me from a casual listener to a dedicated aficionado.

Accompanied Recitative & Aria No 9

Here is a second aria with some of the Accompanied Recitative leading to the aria. Accompanied Recitative is the text of the story orchestrated. Recitative is the story sometimes merely spoken to the audience or as in this example, sung. This tells the audience what is happening at this moment in the story.

Accompanied Recitative & Aria No 9 – 6:17 minutes

O Giunia! … Oh that name! …
The very thought, my friend, that I might lose her,
Quells any surge of my wrath.

But hasten, fly at my side, slay the tyrant …
Ye gods, and now my wife is delivered up
To my enemy, alas! … Who defends her?
And what if he should come his way? … Dear God!
How harsh the contrast,
What grief, immortal gods! Fear, trouble,
Anger, hope, all these I feel within my breast,
And know not which feeling will triumph!
What thoughts are these? And am I still not resolved?
Let Giunia be saved, or at her side I will die.

No. 9 – Aria

This fateful trembling
Growing and growing in my breast,
I know not whether it be hope,
I know not whether it be wrath.

Yet, whether in its inward feeling
Or in its outward wrath
It be madness or hope,
It shall strike terror in the traitor’s heart.

Aria Sung by Julia Varady

This entire sequence listened to shows the depth of emotion an aria can convey. Cecilio is an enemy to Lucio Silla, the reigning Roman Emperor. Giunia thought Silla had killed Cecilio. Silla routinely destroyed all competition to power including his Senate of which Cecilio is a member. Silla killed Giunia’s father. Silla is infatuated with Giunia and wants her as a bride. Giunia refuses Silla. Cecilio is outraged at Silla for these actions against his beloved.

This aria is a soliloquy. The music is as an important component as the vocals. Here, Mozart shows his skill in sweeping us forward in the story, controlling and steering the emotions with the music. The notes set the emotions and stage the vocals. The intertwining of instruments and voice display Mozart’s genius. These two arias represent only a small portion of this opera. There are duets and choral numbers as outstanding and moving as these two arias.

When learning a new art form or language, it is best to take it in short amounts. I am hopeful that the reader clicked on the links to the arias and enjoyed the experience. Thank you for reading this article.

To be continued………………….

Recommended Read:

The New York Times Essential Library: Opera: A Critic’s Guide to the 100 Most Important Works and the Best Recordings By Anthony Tommasini, Publisher: New York Times 2004 ISBN-13: 978-0805074598

This book is an excellent guide to the person who is new to opera. The author provides a brief synopsis of the opera as well as anecdotal information about his preferred performances. He includes recommended CD’s to include in the home library. The author also provides an essay on the composers listed. He includes a top twenty list of must-have operas.

Come Where Love Invites You

Come where love invites you,
Come, for I already feel in my breast
the joy that soon shall be yours.

The sea is not always hostile.
The sky is not always stormy.

Sometimes it smiles happily in calmness and serenity.

In Italian: No. 1 Aria: Vieni ov’amor t’invita JE Golnia

Vieni ov’amor t’invita
Vieni, che gia mi sento
Del tuo vicin contento
Gli alti presage in sen.

Non è sempre il mar cruccioso,
Non è sempre il ciel turbato
Ride alfin, lieto, e piacato
Fra la calma, ed il seren.

Lucio Silla K 135
Opera by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Libretto by Giovanni de Gamerra
Premier performance December 1772
Photo credit: JE Golenia: Sea and Sky